True Left

Politics => Volunteer => Topic started by: guest30 on March 04, 2021, 08:39:16 pm


Title: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 04, 2021, 08:39:16 pm
I am not native English/Anglo people so my English language is not much good, by the way I hate/get tired use language from oppressor or colonialist country, but I want to contribute, what I can do is educate people around me about your anti-Zionist and anti-Jewish political world view with local language spoken by people around me

And I am a muslim, so anti-Jewish and anti-Israel is common for me and people around me, because I live in muslim majority region
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 04, 2021, 11:02:27 pm
Please list your skills/knowledge/resources.

"local language"

OK, but we need to be able to check your content to ensure you are representing our worldview accurately. So it would be helpful to include an English version as well as a local language version of whatever content you produce.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 09, 2021, 06:17:46 am
I already make a site, its new, not yet perfect but there is English translation available

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 09, 2021, 09:31:16 pm
Well done, and welcome to our network! Let us know each time you post a new article, so that we can offer feedback.

I hope to see you eventually present a comprehensive history of Western colonialism in the region:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indonesia#Colonial_era

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dutch_East_Indies

with as much detail as possible about:

1) the colonialists' cruelty towards the colonized populations, and how the colonialists altered the local culture;
2) your own ideas on how to recover pre-colonial Nusantaran culture;
3) how it is the moral duty of Nusantarans to sincerely ally with all other victims of Dutch colonialism (put this map on your blog!):

(https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/9/93/DutchEmpire15.png/800px-DutchEmpire15.png)

(and, more broadly, of Western colonialism as a whole) to ultimately eliminate the Netherlands as a Western country (and, more broadly, eliminate Western civilization as a whole) from existence:

(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/C7IvenBXwAESUn5.jpg:large)

 and what individuals can do in service towards this objective:

https://trueleft.createaforum.com/issues/operation-gaddafi/

Title: My thoughts on Analyzing Russia foreign policy
Post by: guest30 on March 09, 2021, 10:30:39 pm
From my blog :

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/10/observation-foreign-policy-russia/ (My new post)

The new quality of Russian foreign policy – its dynamic balance – is shown most clearly in the Middle East, especially with the start of military operations in Syria in 2015. Here Moscow occupies a unique position as a player capable of maintaining productive contact with all important forces in the region, including the most stubborn antagonists such as Iran and Israel.

.....

In addition to the export of energy resources, weapons, nuclear technology, and foodstuffs, Russia acts as a military and diplomatic player that provides political protection to a number of countries, offering its services as a security guarantee. Under this cover, Russia is active outside Europe and Asia: Russia's profile has increased in the Middle East, as well as in Africa and Latin America.

.....

My conclusion : Russia for 20 years until now has the nature of a neutral political view, does not incline to support the alliance of Western countries and also to non-Western countries, and takes cooperation relations with other countries with the main goal of maintaining the security and economic balance of itself, in our view as a country in Southeast Asia that was once colonized and oppressed by Western countries, Russia which is also one of the countries with the strongest military power in the world and also a country famous for selling a lot of weaponry to other countries, especially non-Western countries, have the potential to work together, especially in the military and economic fields in order to strengthen our country to prevent attacks from Western countries both frontally and implicitly.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 09, 2021, 11:26:45 pm
"as a country in Southeast Asia that was once colonized and oppressed by Western countries, Russia which is also one of the countries with the strongest military power in the world and also a country famous for selling a lot of weaponry to other countries, especially non-Western countries, have the potential to work together, especially in the military and economic fields in order to strengthen our country to prevent attacks from Western countries both frontally and implicitly."

If you maintain this view, we will stop promoting you.

Firstly, Russia itself is a Western country. We already went through this here:

https://trueleft.createaforum.com/questions-debates/aryanism's-hostility-towards-russia-and-eastern-european-people/

We will not accept in our movement any blog which describes Russia as a non-Western country.

Secondly, Russia itself was one of the Western colonial powers:

https://trueleft.createaforum.com/colonial-era/russia-the-last-colonial-empire/

https://trueleft.createaforum.com/colonial-era/alaska/

therefore our attitude towards it should be no different than that towards the other Western colonial powers.

I have no problem with you pragmatically advocating taking advantage of Russian willingness to supply you with what you need to become strong if no one else is available to help you at the moment, but there must never be any theme of sincere fellowship with Russia (so don't use terms such as "work together"). On the contrary, there must be sharp awareness of the need to avoid ever becoming dependent on Russia, and hence a constant search for alternative suppliers (preferably fellow victims of Western colonialism).

By the way, there is no such thing as "Southeast Asia". "Asia" is a Western concept whose use we are trying to discontinue.

"Europe and Asia:
...
Africa"

Put "" around all these terms if you cannot avoid using them. All these are Western concepts whose use we are trying to discontinue.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 10, 2021, 11:23:53 pm
"If you maintain this view, we will stop promoting you.

Firstly, Russia itself is a Western country. We already went through this here:"

.....

Thanks for the advice

Now, I have a new post that discuss about the difference between Colonialism and Imperialism, feel free to correct my writings :

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/11/difference-colonialism-and-imperialism/
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 10, 2021, 11:50:36 pm
I will not look at your new post until you have edited your previous one according to my feedback.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 11, 2021, 12:24:40 am
"I will not look at your new post until you have edited your previous one according to my feedback."

I already change my conclusion, your advice and warnings are appreciated

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/10/observation-foreign-policy-russia/

Conclusion : Russia for 20 years until now has the nature of a neutral political view, does not incline to support the alliance of Western countries and also to non-Western countries, and takes cooperation relations with other countries with the main goal of maintaining the security and economic balance of itself, in our view as a people of country that was once colonized and oppressed by Western countries, Russia which is also one of the countries with the strongest military power in the world and also a country famous for selling a lot of weaponry to other countries, especially non-Western countries, have the potential to us make an arms trade, in order to strengthen our country to prevent attacks from Western countries both frontally and implicitly. Unfortunately, Russia is still being part of the West both culturally and politically, altough she (Russia) have a good relations with many non-Western countries, but Russia still make a good political view towards the last remaining colonizer country in the world, Israel, for us, as a fellow victims of Western colonialism, we not accept such political view, but for the sake of rapid rearmament for security and military power of our homeland, we must do this arms trade deal
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 11, 2021, 02:19:32 am
Quote
Russia for 20 years until now has the nature of a neutral political view, does not incline to support the alliance of Western countries and also to non-Western countries

Change "Western" to "NATO" and "non-Western" to "NAM".

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/NATO

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non-Aligned_Movement

Quote
(Russia) have a good relations with many non-Western countries

Change "have" to "pretends to have".
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 11, 2021, 02:47:18 am
"Change "Western" to "NATO" and "non-Western" to "NAM"."

.....

"Change "have" to "pretends to have"."

This is my renewed conclusion :

Russia for 20 years until now has the nature of a neutral political view, does not incline to support the alliance of NATO and also to Non-Aligned Movement (NAM) countries, and takes cooperation relations with other countries with the main goal of maintaining the security and economic balance of itself, in our view as a people of country that was once colonized and oppressed by Western countries, Russia which is also one of the countries with the strongest military power in the world and also a country famous for selling a lot of weaponry to other countries, especially non-Western countries, have the potential to us make an arms trade, in order to strengthen our country to prevent attacks from Western countries both frontally and implicitly. Unfortunately, Russia is still being part of the West both culturally and politically, so, undoubtly she (Russia) pretends to have a good relations with many non-Western countries, and Russia still make a good political view towards the last remaining colonizer country in the world, Israel, for us, as a fellow victims of Western colonialism, we not accept such political view, but for the sake of rapid rearmament for security and military power of our homeland, we must do this arms trade deal
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 11, 2021, 05:25:05 am
Thank you. Now onto the new article:

Quote
Colonialism is a war to conquer a certain territory or region, then take advantage by taking property and anything that belongs to the conquered area, utilizing the people/people of the conquered area by hiring them for the benefit and benefit of the conquering nation, but the people of the conquered region are treated as inferior or differently, even worse, to be oppressed, persecuted, even made a forced laborer or slave, than people of the conquering nation who were treated higher or better than them, and those who were conquered were not given the opportunity to be united as part of the conquering people, so that the people of the conquered nation could be treated justly by being given the same opportunity as the conquering people, this kind of thing shows the injustice and cruelty of the ruling nation

Replace "conquer" with "steal", and so on. See below.

Quote
Imperialism is also the same, conquering and controlling a certain territory or nation, and people from the controlled areas are given the opportunity to be part of the ruling nation

Remove "also the same". "Replace "ruling nation" with "citizens of the ruling state"

Quote
and given the opportunity to be treated as how the people of the ruling nation are treated,

Here, replace "people of the ruling nation" with "existing citizens of the ruling state".

Quote
such treatment can make the ruling nation act fairly towards the people of the nation or the controlled region.

Again, replace "ruling nation" with "ruling state".

Conquest is the process whereby one state takes the territory of another state. There is no "ruling nation". Only in colonialism is there a ruling nation, hence we say colonialists steal territory from natives.

Quote
colonization or colonialism of Western countries

Replace "of" with "by".

Quote
everyone of a different race or background is considered inferior, whereas among them are not all bad, some behave better/ noble. So, we should judge and treat people by looking at every behavior of one person that we observe, not seeing people from different racial backgrounds, and immediately considering them inferior and ugly, because in every racial group there must be those who are good and we need to treat them well

"" around "race"/"racial", please. (Or use the term "ethnicity"/"ethnic" instead.)

Quote
One important motive for the Netherlands to expand its territory in the Archipelago – in addition to its financial advantages – was to prevent other European countries from taking parts of the region.

"" around "European", please.

Also, you may wish to explain that this is an absurd excuse. If the Dutch sincerely cared about preventing e.g. the French from taking Nusantara, they could have threatened to invade France if the French invaded Nusantara. Of course they did not, therefore such a claim by the Dutch is bullshit.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 11, 2021, 07:08:03 am
"Thank you. Now onto the new article:"

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/11/difference-colonialism-and-imperialism/

I already change the words which needed to be changed, and also give a statement on Netherlands reason to expands it's colonial territory in Nusantara archipelago
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 11, 2021, 10:39:34 pm
"give a statement on Netherlands reason"

Well done! This also relates to the point you made here:

Quote
The Dutch East Indies had two classes for a citizen; “European” and indigenous.

Think about what this means. It means someone from a different Western colonial power who never paid taxes to the Netherlands, but who is "white", is viewed as more important than someone who has been paying taxes to the Netherlands, but who is "non-white". In other words, it is not just that Dutch colonialists feel closer to other Dutch colonialists than to those whom they are colonizing (which is bad enough), but that Dutch colonialists feel closer even to their rival colonialists(!) than to those whom they are colonizing. This is what "whiteness" means.

By the way, is there a particular reason why you chose this map:

https://i1.wp.com/kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Peta-Daerah-Jajahan-Belanda.png

rather than the one I posted above which is more complete?

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/93/DutchEmpire15.png
.
Note in particular my map shows the Dutch possessions in Iran. Since we are currently trying to encourage all former victims of Western colonialism to support present-day Iran, it is important for people to be aware that Iran was historically colonized by the Dutch also.

Also, you may wish to consider expanding this page:

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/about-2/

In particular, you should emphasize that your blog is a True Left blog, and explain what this means.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 11, 2021, 11:38:35 pm
"By the way, is there a particular reason why you chose this map:

https://i1.wp.com/kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/03/Peta-Daerah-Jajahan-Belanda.png

rather than the one I posted above which is more complete?

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/9/93/DutchEmpire15.png
.
Note in particular my map shows the Dutch possessions in Iran. Since we are currently trying to encourage all former victims of Western colonialism to support present-day Iran, it is important for people to be aware that Iran was historically colonized by the Dutch also."

I already change the map into the Dutch colonial world map you proposed, its more complete, I wish you see my post again

"Also, you may wish to consider expanding this page:

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/about-2/

"In particular, you should emphasize that your blog is a True Left blog, and explain what this means."

I need to compromise with people around me, in my region, anything about left wing idea or political view is considered a "Communist", and its view (Communist) is forbidden in society, if I introduce my political view to people as a leftist, I will get angry response from them, people around me will not agree and follow my political view, and the worst thing is and I will get a criminal charge if someone who dislike me report to the police, so I just explain that my website is discuss about politics and history, and my political goal is try to make Islamist groups and parties, which its considered right wing in my country's political map by government's officials, agree with my view, so their anti-Western and anti-Jewish feeling increased more, and I hope my region or country's government will be dominated by them (Islamist groups), and will be serious to implement anti-Western and anti-Zionist view, both politically and diplomatically
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 12, 2021, 12:20:28 am
"anything about left wing idea or political view is considered a "Communist""

Perhaps at some point you could write a post explaining why communism is False Left?

"I hope my region or country's government will be dominated by them (Islamist groups), and will be serious to implement anti-Western and anti-Zionist view, both politically and diplomatically"

The population of Indonesia is 270 million You should think about deploying this considerable demographic strength by strategic emigration to other countries.

The population of the Netherlands is only 17 million. A few million people from Indonesia migrating to the Netherlands will not significantly affect Indonesia, but could totally alter the political landscape in the Netherlands.

The population of Australia is only 25 million. Same thing applies.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 12, 2021, 12:46:41 am
"Perhaps at some point you could write a post explaining why communism is False Left?"

Communist (False-Left) ideology forbidden in my region because remembering tragedy or events that resulting mass killings of people and many government military high officials in end of September 1965 by so-called "Communist" people, in fact not, but by army officials who pretend to be a "Communist" who also work with secret agent from Western countries (British and United States) to make a claim that the Left wing parties, like Communist is dangerous, so Sukarno, leader of Nusantara who so close with False-Left Communist people and world view has a reason to be overthrown by the opposition people like army officials Suharto, Kemal Idris, etc, and replaced by pro-Western government by puppet-leader (Suharto)

If I write anything about Communist, including observe it, it take a high risk, better I write to explain that Islamist ideology is actually in left wing political spectrum, because there is socialist idea in its teaching, and its compatible for people around me, because in my country, majority of people are already being muslims

"The population of Indonesia is 270 million You should think about deploying this considerable demographic strength by strategic emigration to other countries.

The population of the Netherlands is only 17 million. A few million people from Indonesia migrating to the Netherlands will not significantly affect Indonesia, but could totally alter the political landscape in the Netherlands.

The population of Australia is only 25 million. Same thing applies."

A good strategy to defeat the West without any major war
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 15, 2021, 07:13:55 am
My newest article :

Fellow Muslims Must Help Each Other

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/15/fellow-muslim-obligatory-help/

If any from my post there is something wrong, correct me
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 15, 2021, 11:31:54 pm
Nothing is wrong as such, but at present there is not much argumentation going on. I suggest you list the arguments used by those who oppose solidarity, and then counter their arguments one by one. Only then will readers see that your position makes more sense.
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 21, 2021, 04:59:41 pm
My newest website post, about the bad side of Western economic system :

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/22/ugliness-system-economy-modern/
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 22, 2021, 10:04:44 pm
Newest post : Western colonialism is bad for the world

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/23/colonialism-bad-for-the-world/
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 22, 2021, 10:27:16 pm
First article:

Quote
We need to use another economic system, which makes people’s lives better and freer from unnecessary debts from the “modern” Western economic system, for example, an economic system where money is printed or made according to the amount of gold a government or state has

We are opposed to metal-backed money. A national currency backed by gold will have its value subject to alteration by the quantity of gold available in other countries, thus is not independent. The only way for a national currency to be independent is for it to be backed by national labour.

Second article:

Quote
If Western colonialism is beneficial for the colonized people, then in the historical recording of colonialism there will not be an event of rebellion carried out by those who colonized

This would imply that no rebels in history were ever misled. Are you sure about this?? I suggest you come up with a better argument about why Western colonialism is bad that does not depend on whether or not rebellion occurred. (In many Western colonies there were no rebellions; that does not imply colonialism was good in those places.)

Quote
when they were colonized by white people

Missing "" around "white".
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 23, 2021, 12:59:35 am
Quote
We are opposed to metal-backed money. A national currency backed by gold will have its value subject to alteration by the quantity of gold available in other countries, thus is not independent. The only way for a national currency to be independent is for it to be backed by national labour.

Alright, I change the conclusion, this is the renewed conclusion :

We need to use another economic system, which makes people's lives better and freer from unnecessary debts from the "modern" Western economic system, for example, an economic system where money is printed or made according to the amount of labour a government or state has, so, the amount of money which spread by the government to people fit with how many people deserve to get money from their work for the state, from that system, there is no condition where the state lack of money to give to the people, or have excess of money, which make the reserve of the money can misused by the state leader, government officials, or a group of ruling people who control the money, and the value of a country's currency will survive changes in currency values that occur in the world. Not a financial system where a group of people can manage a state-owned bank, so that every money is printed , then the government and the people owe it to those who manage the bank.

Quote
This would imply that no rebels in history were ever misled. Are you sure about this?? I suggest you come up with a better argument about why Western colonialism is bad that does not depend on whether or not rebellion occurred. (In many Western colonies there were no rebellions; that does not imply colonialism was good in those places.)

This is my renewed comments :

If Western colonialism is beneficial for the colonized people, then in the historical recording of colonialism there will not be an event of rebellion carried out by those who colonized, if we look at the history of Western colonialism over the last 500 years, there are many wars of rebellion, the natives experienced slavery committed by the colonizers, they are made as forced laborers who are treated badly until they are exhausted, there are even those who die because of it, and most importantly and need to know, in almost every colonized territory, the people from the colonial country, especially the European "white" people who lived there treated the colonized people with different or discriminating treatment, Europeans get better treatment, for example, if in a colony there is a place where there is good land for plantations and shelter, then the colonizers considered the land their own, even though the land was already owned by the colonized people, and they could take the land by force if the colonized people refused to give it to them, and if the colonizers succeeded in seizing that good land, the colonized people were expelled and they were forced to live in a place that was not suitable for habitation and made a place to live, so that many of them live uncomfortable and in torment, such colonial atittude like that cannot be forgotten and forgiven

Quote
Missing "" around "white".

And the notion that people in the "South" were experiencing backwardness and economic poverty was also not entirely true, before the Europeans colonized, they could live in good economic circumstances, their basic needs such as food and housing needs had been obtained, and when they were colonized by "white" people from Western European countries, their basic needs were much taken by force by those who colonized by force , most through wars between colonial forces and colonized natives, so that they lived in poverty, here is a further explanation that explains that Western colonialism was more bad


Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest30 on March 30, 2021, 08:34:35 am
My newest post, include short documentary video, "International" (English) language available :

https://kameradbaren.wpcomstaging.com/en/2021/03/30/brother-muslim-we-in-russia/
Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: guest5 on March 30, 2021, 09:42:56 pm
Iran crisis of 1946
Quote
The Iran crisis of 1946, also known as the Azerbaijan Crisis (Persian: غائله آذربایجان‎, romanized: Qaʾilih Âzarbâyjân) in the Iranian sources, was one of the first crises of the Cold War, sparked by the refusal of Joseph Stalin's Soviet Union to relinquish occupied Iranian territory, despite repeated assurances. The end of World War II should have resulted in the end of the Allied joint occupation of Iran. Instead, Pro-Soviet Iranians proclaimed the separatist Azerbaijan People's Government[5] and the Kurdish separatist Republic of Mahabad. The United States pressure on the Soviet Union to withdraw is the earliest evidence of success with the new strategy of Truman Doctrine and containment.

In August–September 1941, Pahlavi Iran had been jointly invaded and occupied by the Allied powers of the Soviet Red Army in the north and by the British in the centre and south.[6] Iran was used by the Americans and the British as a transportation route to provide vital supplies to the Soviet Union's war efforts.[6]

In the aftermath of the occupation of Iran, those Allied forces agreed to withdraw from Iran within six months after the cessation of hostilities.[6] However, when this deadline came in early 1946, the Soviets, under Joseph Stalin, remained in Iran. Soon, the alliance of the Kurdish and People's Azerbaijani forces, supported in arms and training by the Soviet Union, engaged in fighting with Iranian forces,[1] resulting in a total of 2,000 casualties. Negotiation by Iranian premier Ahmad Qavam and diplomatic pressure on the Soviets by the United States eventually led to Soviet withdrawal and dissolution of the separatist Azeri and Kurdish states.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iran_crisis_of_1946

Stalin's Jews
Quote
We mustn't forget that some of greatest murderers of modern times were Jewish
https://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3342999,00.html

Russians in Israel
Quote
People of full or partial non-Jewish ethnic Russian ancestry number around 300,000 of the Israeli population from the immigrants from the Soviet Union and post-Soviet states,[1][2] and the number of Russian passport holders living in Israel is in the hundreds of thousands.[3]

Most Russian people in Israel have full Israeli citizenship and are involved in the country's economy on all levels.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russians_in_Israel
(https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/ee/Joseph_Dunford_visit_to_Israel%2C_May_2017_DSC_3504_%2834446273302%29.jpg)

How a series of deadly Russian apartment bombings in 1999 led to Putin's rise to power
Quote
David Satter is a US journalist who spent decades covering Russian politics before he was expelled from the country after claiming that President Putin and the FSB may have been involved with the deadly Russia apartment bombings in 1999.
https://www.businessinsider.com/how-the-1999-russian-apartment-bombings-led-to-putins-rise-to-power-2018-3

See also: https://trueleft.createaforum.com/colonial-era/russia-the-last-colonial-empire/
Quote
Russia is a colonial empire that has “persistently denied its colonial nature,” Khodarkovsky explained.

Title: Re: I want to contribute as much as I can
Post by: 90sRetroFan on March 30, 2021, 10:20:49 pm
You had been warned:

Quote
If you maintain this view, we will stop promoting you.

You did not listen. We do not tolerate traitors.