I also have no issue with Germany for the Germans and America for the Americans and believe we are doing a disservice by pretending that isn't a part of National Socialism.
I have an issue with it, because people should be able to choose where they live. Nobody chooses to be born in a specific place, and it would require initiated violence to keep people out, which we're against. Plus, that very sentence underlines the issue: Germany and America are totally different examples and they aren't comparable at all. What's an American? Americans can be "white", or "black", or Native American, or any of a number of other ethnicities. Americans aren't defined by ethnicity to begin with, and yet you're using it as an example to justify keeping Germany ethnically pure.
But the idea that Hitler's views of black people didn't change after mein kampf is ridiculous
In their defense, 90sRetroFan's position isn't that Hitler's views changed after Mein Kampf. The position is that Mein Kampf was written to bolster himself as a politician.
There is a huge difference. There were not 4 different colors of people building Germany. Its not about ethnicity its about blood. If all Americans traced their ancestry back to 1800 as required by Germany, black people would not be excluded. And it goes without saying that Americans from the arctic to Chile would be deemed Americans. Also America is a different nation than Germany, and what we want to preserve was built on noble people from all over the world. The same can not be said for Germany. And the initiated violence would undoubtedly be the attempt to rule over a people you did not help build.
There is absolutely nothing in national socialism that suggests anyone should be able to have power anywhere. Move there, yes, integrate, if possible, but it would be a disastrous and ridiculous idea to say an Englishman should have power in Mexico, or a swede power in Japan. Although if something is superior it should always be integrated. My disagreement here is not with national socialism, but with a rather minor policy of anet. Blood is important to us right? How does that translate into letting just anyone from anywhere rule over Americans or Germans or Arabs.
But you are 100% correct about Mein Kampf