https://www.yahoo.com/news/though-haiti-dire-security-needs-035120293.htmlThis July marks two years since Haiti’s President Jovenel Moïse was shot dead inside his home. With the country mired in crisis, it is virtually impossible to get hold of regular supplies of water or fuel, or to access healthcare services because of the violence.
As I keep saying, transporting supplies to where the people in need are will always fail. The correct approach is to transport the people in need to where the supplies are.
The International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) team working in Port-au-Prince has seen a substantial increase in the presence and reach of armed groups in Haiti, now numbering up to 300 gangs both within and beyond the capital, which is now mostly under their control. It’s no surprise, then, that the dominant narrative about Haiti focuses on insecurity and whether or how to answer calls for the deployment of international forces to intervene and restore order.
NO, DO NOT INVADE! The
only role of international forces should be to provide transport for any Haitians wishing to leave Haiti! It is that simple.
Yet this laser focus on the security situation has crowded out an equally important conversation: how to make tangible progress in meeting Haitians’ basic needs
How? Get them out of Haiti and into the US ASAP, that's how! (Though really France should also be stepping up to take them in. I would be all for the US pressuring France to accept all Haitians who themselves wish to relocate to France in the long-term.)
There are several Haitian and international organizations working hard to alleviate that suffering, but they are in need of more funding and resources.
As the regional director for the Americas for the ICRC, I fear that a singular narrative about security in the country draws support and attention away from critical humanitarian relief, which could ultimately shrink our ability and that of others to continue to provide assistance.
Then do not provide assistance in Haiti, but provide assistance in the US, and get Haitians in need of assistance into the US!
Half of Haiti’s residents are experiencing hunger, and only slightly more have access to safe drinking water.
That's how many Haitians should be in the US by now.
Haiti’s profound humanitarian needs are alarming and on the scale of those my organization sees in armed conflicts around the world, covered heavily in the news. But the narrative that exists outside of Haiti is that the situation is so dire achieving results is impossible, creating a sense of hopelessness and fatigue.
The narrative is not wrong. Haiti's carrying capacity has been reduced. There is no getting around this. The only way to achieve results is for Haitians to emigrate until the remaining population falls back below the new carrying capacity.
That’s why the international community must support Haiti — not abandon it — in finding a viable political solution and to strengthen the efforts of humanitarian and development actors, both national and international, which right now are addressing the needs of the most vulnerable.
NO! Haiti requires no "political solution" and no "development". The current carrying capacity in Haiti is actually closer to what it used to be prior to the colonial era, which is a good thing. Stop trying to artificially pump the carrying capacity back up to colonial-era levels! Just leave it as it is and get the excess Haitians into the US!
And it must start a new conversation, one that moves beyond a security-centric narrative and embraces a compassionate, inclusive, and forward-looking approach in Haiti.
You cannot be both compassionate and forward-looking. True compassion is always regressive. True compassion always prefers the bad thing to never have happened to the victim in the first place, whereas progressiveness tries to turn every bad thing that happened to the victim into a chance for the victim to "grow" (ie. desensitize) from the experience (until the victim eventually becomes glad that the bad thing happened - this is what progress actually means). This is the opposite of compassion: it is sadomasochism.
Related:
https://trueleft.createaforum.com/true-left-vs-false-left/leftists-against-progressivism/